前言
JavaScript攻击属于Web前端安全,不存在黑盒测试的概念,直接可以对JS进行白盒代码审计。
DVWA中的JavaScript攻击的场景是基于token由前端JS生成而引起的一系列问题。
LOW
分析
打开页面如下;
输入ChangeMe,显示错误;
输入success,显示不合法token值;
怀疑前端回直接修改token,查看前端源码,发现隐藏输入token;
1 | <form name="low_js" method="post"> |
根据隐藏token的值,猜测是MD5加密,查看源码;
1 | <?php |
实现了对输入的phrase进行一次rot13后再进行一次MD5加密;
提示要求输入success,此处猜测要提取MD5(rot13(“sucess”))作为token值,在浏览器控制栏计算该MD5值;
前端更改隐藏输入的值,再次输入success后显示成功;
MEDIUM
分析
查看前端源码,发现和LOW级别类似,只是将JavaScript代码放在了文件中引用;
1 | <form name="low_js" method="post"> |
JavaScript代码如下;
1 | function do_something(e){ |
分析代码,其功能是将phrase变量的值逆序;
只需要在输入框输入 “success” 后,在控制台中,输入do_elsesomething("XX")
,再点击提交即可;
HIGH
分析
HIGH级别和MEDIUM级别类似,生成token的逻辑在JavaScript文件中;
1 | var a=['fromCharCode','toString','replace','BeJ','\x5cw+','Lyg','SuR','(w(){\x273M\x203L\x27;q\x201l=\x273K\x203I\x203J\x20T\x27;q\x201R=1c\x202I===\x271n\x27;q\x20Y=1R?2I:{};p(Y.3N){1R=1O}q\x202L=!1R&&1c\x202M===\x271n\x27;q\x202o=!Y.2S&&1c\x202d===\x271n\x27&&2d.2Q&&2d.2Q.3S;p(2o){Y=3R}z\x20p(2L){Y=2M}q\x202G=!Y.3Q&&1c\x202g===\x271n\x27&&2g.X;q\x202s=1c\x202l===\x27w\x27&&2l.3P;q\x201y=!Y.3H&&1c\x20Z!==\x272T\x27;q\x20m=\x273G\x27.3z(\x27\x27);q\x202w=[-3y,3x,3v,3w];q\x20U=[24,16,8,0];q\x20K=[3A,3B,3F,3E,3D,3C,3T,3U,4d,4c,4b,49,4a,4e,4f,4j,4i,4h,3u,48,47,3Z,3Y,3X,3V,3W,40,41,46,45,43,42,4k,3f,38,36,39,37,34,33,2Y,31,2Z,35,3t,3n,3m,3l,3o,3p,3s,3r,3q,3k,3j,3d,3a,3c,3b,3e,3h,3g,3i,4g];q\x201E=[\x271e\x27,\x2727\x27,\x271G\x27,\x272R\x27];q\x20l=[];p(Y.2S||!1z.1K){1z.1K=w(1x){A\x204C.Q.2U.1I(1x)===\x27[1n\x201z]\x27}}p(1y&&(Y.50||!Z.1N)){Z.1N=w(1x){A\x201c\x201x===\x271n\x27&&1x.1w&&1x.1w.1J===Z}}q\x202m=w(1X,x){A\x20w(s){A\x20O\x20N(x,1d).S(s)[1X]()}};q\x202a=w(x){q\x20P=2m(\x271e\x27,x);p(2o){P=2P(P,x)}P.1T=w(){A\x20O\x20N(x)};P.S=w(s){A\x20P.1T().S(s)};1g(q\x20i=0;i<1E.W;++i){q\x20T=1E[i];P[T]=2m(T,x)}A\x20P};q\x202P=w(P,x){q\x201S=2O(\x222N(\x271S\x27)\x22);q\x201Y=2O(\x222N(\x271w\x27).1Y\x22);q\x202n=x?\x271H\x27:\x271q\x27;q\x202z=w(s){p(1c\x20s===\x272p\x27){A\x201S.2x(2n).S(s,\x274S\x27).1G(\x271e\x27)}z{p(s===2q||s===2T){1u\x20O\x201t(1l)}z\x20p(s.1J===Z){s=O\x202r(s)}}p(1z.1K(s)||Z.1N(s)||s.1J===1Y){A\x201S.2x(2n).S(O\x201Y(s)).1G(\x271e\x27)}z{A\x20P(s)}};A\x202z};q\x202k=w(1X,x){A\x20w(G,s){A\x20O\x201P(G,x,1d).S(s)[1X]()}};q\x202f=w(x){q\x20P=2k(\x271e\x27,x);P.1T=w(G){A\x20O\x201P(G,x)};P.S=w(G,s){A\x20P.1T(G).S(s)};1g(q\x20i=0;i<1E.W;++i){q\x20T=1E[i];P[T]=2k(T,x)}A\x20P};w\x20N(x,1v){p(1v){l[0]=l[16]=l[1]=l[2]=l[3]=l[4]=l[5]=l[6]=l[7]=l[8]=l[9]=l[10]=l[11]=l[12]=l[13]=l[14]=l[15]=0;k.l=l}z{k.l=[0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0]}p(x){k.C=4I;k.B=4H;k.E=4l;k.F=4U;k.J=4J;k.I=4K;k.H=4L;k.D=4T}z{k.C=4X;k.B=4W;k.E=4Y;k.F=4Z;k.J=4V;k.I=4O;k.H=4F;k.D=4s}k.1C=k.1A=k.L=k.2i=0;k.1U=k.1L=1O;k.2j=1d;k.x=x}N.Q.S=w(s){p(k.1U){A}q\x202h,T=1c\x20s;p(T!==\x272p\x27){p(T===\x271n\x27){p(s===2q){1u\x20O\x201t(1l)}z\x20p(1y&&s.1J===Z){s=O\x202r(s)}z\x20p(!1z.1K(s)){p(!1y||!Z.1N(s)){1u\x20O\x201t(1l)}}}z{1u\x20O\x201t(1l)}2h=1d}q\x20r,M=0,i,W=s.W,l=k.l;4t(M<W){p(k.1L){k.1L=1O;l[0]=k.1C;l[16]=l[1]=l[2]=l[3]=l[4]=l[5]=l[6]=l[7]=l[8]=l[9]=l[10]=l[11]=l[12]=l[13]=l[14]=l[15]=0}p(2h){1g(i=k.1A;M<W&&i<1k;++M){l[i>>2]|=s[M]<<U[i++&3]}}z{1g(i=k.1A;M<W&&i<1k;++M){r=s.1Q(M);p(r<R){l[i>>2]|=r<<U[i++&3]}z\x20p(r<2v){l[i>>2]|=(2t|(r>>6))<<U[i++&3];l[i>>2]|=(R|(r&V))<<U[i++&3]}z\x20p(r<2A||r>=2E){l[i>>2]|=(2D|(r>>12))<<U[i++&3];l[i>>2]|=(R|((r>>6)&V))<<U[i++&3];l[i>>2]|=(R|(r&V))<<U[i++&3]}z{r=2C+(((r&23)<<10)|(s.1Q(++M)&23));l[i>>2]|=(2X|(r>>18))<<U[i++&3];l[i>>2]|=(R|((r>>12)&V))<<U[i++&3];l[i>>2]|=(R|((r>>6)&V))<<U[i++&3];l[i>>2]|=(R|(r&V))<<U[i++&3]}}}k.2u=i;k.L+=i-k.1A;p(i>=1k){k.1C=l[16];k.1A=i-1k;k.1W();k.1L=1d}z{k.1A=i}}p(k.L>4r){k.2i+=k.L/2H<<0;k.L=k.L%2H}A\x20k};N.Q.1s=w(){p(k.1U){A}k.1U=1d;q\x20l=k.l,i=k.2u;l[16]=k.1C;l[i>>2]|=2w[i&3];k.1C=l[16];p(i>=4q){p(!k.1L){k.1W()}l[0]=k.1C;l[16]=l[1]=l[2]=l[3]=l[4]=l[5]=l[6]=l[7]=l[8]=l[9]=l[10]=l[11]=l[12]=l[13]=l[14]=l[15]=0}l[14]=k.2i<<3|k.L>>>29;l[15]=k.L<<3;k.1W()};N.Q.1W=w(){q\x20a=k.C,b=k.B,c=k.E,d=k.F,e=k.J,f=k.I,g=k.H,h=k.D,l=k.l,j,1a,1b,1j,v,1f,1h,1B,1Z,1V,1D;1g(j=16;j<1k;++j){v=l[j-15];1a=((v>>>7)|(v<<25))^((v>>>18)|(v<<14))^(v>>>3);v=l[j-2];1b=((v>>>17)|(v<<15))^((v>>>19)|(v<<13))^(v>>>10);l[j]=l[j-16]+1a+l[j-7]+1b<<0}1D=b&c;1g(j=0;j<1k;j+=4){p(k.2j){p(k.x){1B=4m;v=l[0]-4n;h=v-4o<<0;d=v+4p<<0}z{1B=4v;v=l[0]-4w;h=v-4G<<0;d=v+4D<<0}k.2j=1O}z{1a=((a>>>2)|(a<<30))^((a>>>13)|(a<<19))^((a>>>22)|(a<<10));1b=((e>>>6)|(e<<26))^((e>>>11)|(e<<21))^((e>>>25)|(e<<7));1B=a&b;1j=1B^(a&c)^1D;1h=(e&f)^(~e&g);v=h+1b+1h+K[j]+l[j];1f=1a+1j;h=d+v<<0;d=v+1f<<0}1a=((d>>>2)|(d<<30))^((d>>>13)|(d<<19))^((d>>>22)|(d<<10));1b=((h>>>6)|(h<<26))^((h>>>11)|(h<<21))^((h>>>25)|(h<<7));1Z=d&a;1j=1Z^(d&b)^1B;1h=(h&e)^(~h&f);v=g+1b+1h+K[j+1]+l[j+1];1f=1a+1j;g=c+v<<0;c=v+1f<<0;1a=((c>>>2)|(c<<30))^((c>>>13)|(c<<19))^((c>>>22)|(c<<10));1b=((g>>>6)|(g<<26))^((g>>>11)|(g<<21))^((g>>>25)|(g<<7));1V=c&d;1j=1V^(c&a)^1Z;1h=(g&h)^(~g&e);v=f+1b+1h+K[j+2]+l[j+2];1f=1a+1j;f=b+v<<0;b=v+1f<<0;1a=((b>>>2)|(b<<30))^((b>>>13)|(b<<19))^((b>>>22)|(b<<10));1b=((f>>>6)|(f<<26))^((f>>>11)|(f<<21))^((f>>>25)|(f<<7));1D=b&c;1j=1D^(b&d)^1V;1h=(f&g)^(~f&h);v=e+1b+1h+K[j+3]+l[j+3];1f=1a+1j;e=a+v<<0;a=v+1f<<0}k.C=k.C+a<<0;k.B=k.B+b<<0;k.E=k.E+c<<0;k.F=k.F+d<<0;k.J=k.J+e<<0;k.I=k.I+f<<0;k.H=k.H+g<<0;k.D=k.D+h<<0};N.Q.1e=w(){k.1s();q\x20C=k.C,B=k.B,E=k.E,F=k.F,J=k.J,I=k.I,H=k.H,D=k.D;q\x201e=m[(C>>28)&o]+m[(C>>24)&o]+m[(C>>20)&o]+m[(C>>16)&o]+m[(C>>12)&o]+m[(C>>8)&o]+m[(C>>4)&o]+m[C&o]+m[(B>>28)&o]+m[(B>>24)&o]+m[(B>>20)&o]+m[(B>>16)&o]+m[(B>>12)&o]+m[(B>>8)&o]+m[(B>>4)&o]+m[B&o]+m[(E>>28)&o]+m[(E>>24)&o]+m[(E>>20)&o]+m[(E>>16)&o]+m[(E>>12)&o]+m[(E>>8)&o]+m[(E>>4)&o]+m[E&o]+m[(F>>28)&o]+m[(F>>24)&o]+m[(F>>20)&o]+m[(F>>16)&o]+m[(F>>12)&o]+m[(F>>8)&o]+m[(F>>4)&o]+m[F&o]+m[(J>>28)&o]+m[(J>>24)&o]+m[(J>>20)&o]+m[(J>>16)&o]+m[(J>>12)&o]+m[(J>>8)&o]+m[(J>>4)&o]+m[J&o]+m[(I>>28)&o]+m[(I>>24)&o]+m[(I>>20)&o]+m[(I>>16)&o]+m[(I>>12)&o]+m[(I>>8)&o]+m[(I>>4)&o]+m[I&o]+m[(H>>28)&o]+m[(H>>24)&o]+m[(H>>20)&o]+m[(H>>16)&o]+m[(H>>12)&o]+m[(H>>8)&o]+m[(H>>4)&o]+m[H&o];p(!k.x){1e+=m[(D>>28)&o]+m[(D>>24)&o]+m[(D>>20)&o]+m[(D>>16)&o]+m[(D>>12)&o]+m[(D>>8)&o]+m[(D>>4)&o]+m[D&o]}A\x201e};N.Q.2U=N.Q.1e;N.Q.1G=w(){k.1s();q\x20C=k.C,B=k.B,E=k.E,F=k.F,J=k.J,I=k.I,H=k.H,D=k.D;q\x202b=[(C>>24)&u,(C>>16)&u,(C>>8)&u,C&u,(B>>24)&u,(B>>16)&u,(B>>8)&u,B&u,(E>>24)&u,(E>>16)&u,(E>>8)&u,E&u,(F>>24)&u,(F>>16)&u,(F>>8)&u,F&u,(J>>24)&u,(J>>16)&u,(J>>8)&u,J&u,(I>>24)&u,(I>>16)&u,(I>>8)&u,I&u,(H>>24)&u,(H>>16)&u,(H>>8)&u,H&u];p(!k.x){2b.4A((D>>24)&u,(D>>16)&u,(D>>8)&u,D&u)}A\x202b};N.Q.27=N.Q.1G;N.Q.2R=w(){k.1s();q\x201w=O\x20Z(k.x?28:32);q\x201i=O\x204x(1w);1i.1p(0,k.C);1i.1p(4,k.B);1i.1p(8,k.E);1i.1p(12,k.F);1i.1p(16,k.J);1i.1p(20,k.I);1i.1p(24,k.H);p(!k.x){1i.1p(28,k.D)}A\x201w};w\x201P(G,x,1v){q\x20i,T=1c\x20G;p(T===\x272p\x27){q\x20L=[],W=G.W,M=0,r;1g(i=0;i<W;++i){r=G.1Q(i);p(r<R){L[M++]=r}z\x20p(r<2v){L[M++]=(2t|(r>>6));L[M++]=(R|(r&V))}z\x20p(r<2A||r>=2E){L[M++]=(2D|(r>>12));L[M++]=(R|((r>>6)&V));L[M++]=(R|(r&V))}z{r=2C+(((r&23)<<10)|(G.1Q(++i)&23));L[M++]=(2X|(r>>18));L[M++]=(R|((r>>12)&V));L[M++]=(R|((r>>6)&V));L[M++]=(R|(r&V))}}G=L}z{p(T===\x271n\x27){p(G===2q){1u\x20O\x201t(1l)}z\x20p(1y&&G.1J===Z){G=O\x202r(G)}z\x20p(!1z.1K(G)){p(!1y||!Z.1N(G)){1u\x20O\x201t(1l)}}}z{1u\x20O\x201t(1l)}}p(G.W>1k){G=(O\x20N(x,1d)).S(G).27()}q\x201F=[],2e=[];1g(i=0;i<1k;++i){q\x20b=G[i]||0;1F[i]=4z^b;2e[i]=4y^b}N.1I(k,x,1v);k.S(2e);k.1F=1F;k.2c=1d;k.1v=1v}1P.Q=O\x20N();1P.Q.1s=w(){N.Q.1s.1I(k);p(k.2c){k.2c=1O;q\x202W=k.27();N.1I(k,k.x,k.1v);k.S(k.1F);k.S(2W);N.Q.1s.1I(k)}};q\x20X=2a();X.1q=X;X.1H=2a(1d);X.1q.2V=2f();X.1H.2V=2f(1d);p(2G){2g.X=X}z{Y.1q=X.1q;Y.1H=X.1H;p(2s){2l(w(){A\x20X})}}})();w\x202y(e){1g(q\x20t=\x22\x22,n=e.W-1;n>=0;n--)t+=e[n];A\x20t}w\x202J(t,y=\x224B\x22){1m.1o(\x221M\x22).1r=1q(1m.1o(\x221M\x22).1r+y)}w\x202B(e=\x224E\x22){1m.1o(\x221M\x22).1r=1q(e+1m.1o(\x221M\x22).1r)}w\x202K(a,b){1m.1o(\x221M\x22).1r=2y(1m.1o(\x222F\x22).1r)}1m.1o(\x222F\x22).1r=\x22\x22;4u(w(){2B(\x224M\x22)},4N);1m.1o(\x224P\x22).4Q(\x224R\x22,2J);2K(\x223O\x22,44);','||||||||||||||||||||this|blocks|HEX_CHARS||0x0F|if|var|code|message||0xFF|t1|function|is224||else|return|h1|h0|h7|h2|h3|key|h6|h5|h4||bytes|index|Sha256|new|method|prototype|0x80|update|type|SHIFT|0x3f|length|exports|root|ArrayBuffer|||||||||||s0|s1|typeof|true|hex|t2|for|ch|dataView|maj|64|ERROR|document|object|getElementById|setUint32|sha256|value|finalize|Error|throw|sharedMemory|buffer|obj|ARRAY_BUFFER|Array|start|ab|block|bc|OUTPUT_TYPES|oKeyPad|digest|sha224|call|constructor|isArray|hashed|token|isView|false|HmacSha256|charCodeAt|WINDOW|crypto|create|finalized|cd|hash|outputType|Buffer|da||||0x3ff||||array|||createMethod|arr|inner|process|iKeyPad|createHmacMethod|module|notString|hBytes|first|createHmacOutputMethod|define|createOutputMethod|algorithm|NODE_JS|string|null|Uint8Array|AMD|0xc0|lastByteIndex|0x800|EXTRA|createHash|do_something|nodeMethod|0xd800|token_part_2|0x10000|0xe0|0xe000|phrase|COMMON_JS|4294967296|window|token_part_3|token_part_1|WEB_WORKER|self|require|eval|nodeWrap|versions|arrayBuffer|JS_SHA256_NO_NODE_JS|undefined|toString|hmac|innerHash|0xf0|0xa2bfe8a1|0xc24b8b70||0xa81a664b||0x92722c85|0x81c2c92e|0xc76c51a3|0x53380d13|0x766a0abb|0x4d2c6dfc|0x650a7354|0x748f82ee|0x84c87814|0x78a5636f|0x682e6ff3|0x8cc70208|0x2e1b2138|0xa4506ceb|0x90befffa|0xbef9a3f7|0x5b9cca4f|0x4ed8aa4a|0x106aa070|0xf40e3585|0xd6990624|0x19a4c116|0x1e376c08|0x391c0cb3|0x34b0bcb5|0x2748774c|0xd192e819|0x0fc19dc6|32768|128|8388608|2147483648|split|0x428a2f98|0x71374491|0x59f111f1|0x3956c25b|0xe9b5dba5|0xb5c0fbcf|0123456789abcdef|JS_SHA256_NO_ARRAY_BUFFER|is|invalid|input|strict|use|JS_SHA256_NO_WINDOW|ABCD|amd|JS_SHA256_NO_COMMON_JS|global|node|0x923f82a4|0xab1c5ed5|0x983e5152|0xa831c66d|0x76f988da|0x5cb0a9dc|0x4a7484aa|0xb00327c8|0xbf597fc7|0x14292967|0x06ca6351||0xd5a79147|0xc6e00bf3|0x2de92c6f|0x240ca1cc|0x550c7dc3|0x72be5d74|0x243185be|0x12835b01|0xd807aa98|0x80deb1fe|0x9bdc06a7|0xc67178f2|0xefbe4786|0xe49b69c1|0xc19bf174|0x27b70a85|0x3070dd17|300032|1413257819|150054599|24177077|56|4294967295|0x5be0cd19|while|setTimeout|704751109|210244248|DataView|0x36|0x5c|push|ZZ|Object|143694565|YY|0x1f83d9ab|1521486534|0x367cd507|0xc1059ed8|0xffc00b31|0x68581511|0x64f98fa7|XX|300|0x9b05688c|send|addEventListener|click|utf8|0xbefa4fa4|0xf70e5939|0x510e527f|0xbb67ae85|0x6a09e667|0x3c6ef372|0xa54ff53a|JS_SHA256_NO_ARRAY_BUFFER_IS_VIEW','split'];(function(c,d){var e=function(f){while(--f){c['push'](c['shift']());}};e(++d);}(a,0x1f4));var b=function(c,d){c=c-0x0;var e=a[c];return e;};eval(function(d,e,f,g,h,i){h=function(j){return(j<e?'':h(parseInt(j/e)))+((j=j%e)>0x23?String[b('0x0')](j+0x1d):j[b('0x1')](0x24));};if(!''[b('0x2')](/^/,String)){while(f--){i[h(f)]=g[f]||h(f);}g=[function(k){if('wpA'!==b('0x3')){return i[k];}else{while(f--){i[k(f)]=g[f]||k(f);}g=[function(l){return i[l];}];k=function(){return b('0x4');};f=0x1;}}];h=function(){return b('0x4');};f=0x1;};while(f--){if(g[f]){if(b('0x5')===b('0x6')){return i[h];}else{d=d[b('0x2')](new RegExp('\x5cb'+h(f)+'\x5cb','g'),g[f]);}}}return d;}(b('0x7'),0x3e,0x137,b('0x8')[b('0x9')]('|'),0x0,{})); |
分析JavaScript代码,已经做了混淆;
使用在线解码工具http://deobfuscatejavascript.com/#解码如下;
1 | (function() { |
核心代码主要是后面的几个函数;
几个函数调用顺序及生成token的步骤如下:
- 执行token_part_1(),取phrase值并进行字符串翻转处理;
- 延迟300ms后执行token_part_2(),传入参数字符串
XX
和token值拼接并调用sha256()加密; - 点击按钮时执行token_part_3(),将token值和字符串
ZZ
拼接并调用sha256()加密,从而得到最终的token;
先将转换过来的JS前一部分关于sha256算法定义代码输入实现初始化,方便后面直接调用sha256();
在输入框输入 success 后,再到控制台中输入token_part_1("ABCD", 44)
和token_part_2("XX")
,再点击提交即可完成;
IMPOSSIBLE
分析
前端直接表明不能相信不安全的输入,没有输入最安全呗;